...Opening a new store.
For those who don't know, the reason I have been MIA for the past two months is because Borders went out of business, taking my job with it. We (lead by my manager Dorothy) decided to do something crazy, like partner with people who run a toy store and open up our own bookstore.
The store is open now, and anyone who lives near Captiola, CA should come check it out! I will be making posts regularly again soon, hopefully stating today. Thanks for your patience!
Sunday, December 18, 2011
Sunday, October 16, 2011
Bookstores Take a Stand - Comically
As you may have read in the news, DC comics has released 100 of their titles to Amazon exclusively, meaning that the Kindle Fire is the only device that will be able to support them in an electronic format. Don't have the Kindle Fire? You can still get those titles at a brick-and-mortar store, or at least you could until earlier this week when Barnes and Noble decided to pull all of those titles from the shelves.
As you see in the articles, many (including the employees) felt that this step was a little drastic, and would ultimately hurt the company rather than help it. Certainly customers who are unaware of the stakes are unhappy, and even those that are still have to deal with not being able to buy their favorite comics at the stores they like to support. The war for digital content is one that is hard to understand unless you are working in that environment, and even then I can understand the frustration on the store employee's level. When customers depend on you to have the thing that they are seeking, it is hard to have to explain to people that may or may not care that your company has made this decision, and you do not have any way to change it.
That being said, when I first heard about this, I was majorly impressed. Barnes and Noble has been saying for some time now that they will only continue to provide "showroom space" for those titles for which they also have electronic access. (This was in a PW article some months ago, which I cannot find now but I promise my word is good for it.) At the time I thought that this was a load of hot air, quite frankly, because who would risk that much to take a stance against that behemoth of Amazon? Again, I understand the objections to it, but you have to admit to the sheer amount of chutzpah that a move like that takes. I also have no love for Amazon, who does not even have the redeeming aspect of employing booksellers to soften the blow of how many stores they have helped put under. So I admit that I did not regret that DC might have had their noses tweaked a little for relying so heavily on Amazon.
I also think B&N has a point. Booksellers everywhere can understand the frustration of having someone come in, ask you to find a book, and then go buy it online. Watch this video from the Harvard Bookstore, which humorously but accurately depicts the frustration of watching your hard work benefit another company. For Indies, they rely on the goodwill of their customers to support their local bookstore to get people to buy actual paper copies, and people respond to that. B&N, who can't reap the benefits of being a "local", relies on being able to sell their products electronically as well to keep their customers loyal. Without that ability, it really doesn't profit them to keep a title in stock that people will just come in and look at, listen to the employee recommendations, and buy elsewhere.
Do they lose the sales from people not being able to buy the paper copy? Sure, but they've seen what happens when a company relies on just being cheap and there, rather than aggressively expanding into the electronic world. Right or wrong, they seem to be taking a stand against the idea that they exist solely as showroom space, and refuse to participate in a system in which they are not seeing any benefit for themselves.
Now it seems that Books-A-Million has joined the embargo. If I may make a Star Trek reference, it's as if one of the non-aligned worlds has joined the Maquis forces and lent them a semblance of legitimacy so they look less like a spoiled child throwing tantrums over things that they cannot change. It will be interesting to see if this move will sway customer sympathy in their favor. This "alliance" make the issue less about Barnes and Noble, and more about the book industry as a whole. While I'm sure B&N comic book revenue is nothing to sneeze at, adding BAM numbers to the equation makes things a little more serious if DC wants to continue this way.
It will also be interesting to see how the Indies react to this "call to arms". I would venture to say that since there is nothing that would really benefit them to help either Barnes and Noble or BAM, they will probably sit this one out. More than either of these chains, the Indie relies on having the physical product for the regulars and for the walk-ins. They therefore can't really afford to do anything drastic over electronic content, and in any case a lot of them don't offer their own e-reader anyway. However, it may benefit the book-selling industry as whole to remind publishers that they need their showroom as much as book stores need the product.
Surprisingly, I don't really feel strongly one way or the other about this battle. I think it is intensely interesting, and I have always had something of a soft spot for lost causes, but the objections against this move are very valid. Beyond the question of whether or not they are right to be doing what they are doing, there is also the chance that this won't pan out, and they will have alienated their customer base for nothing.
What about you? Do you feel that bookstores have the right to refuse to carry product that they do not have access to electronically? Or do you feel that bookstores have a responsibility to the community that they are in to have the good titles in stock, and that they are only hurting themselves in the long run? I'm curious to hear what people at other bookstores or even those not involved in the industry think. While the book industry has always been rather insular, I think the most important thing going forward is to hear what the concerns and responses are of the community you serve.
After all, isn't that what rebel causes are for?
As you see in the articles, many (including the employees) felt that this step was a little drastic, and would ultimately hurt the company rather than help it. Certainly customers who are unaware of the stakes are unhappy, and even those that are still have to deal with not being able to buy their favorite comics at the stores they like to support. The war for digital content is one that is hard to understand unless you are working in that environment, and even then I can understand the frustration on the store employee's level. When customers depend on you to have the thing that they are seeking, it is hard to have to explain to people that may or may not care that your company has made this decision, and you do not have any way to change it.
That being said, when I first heard about this, I was majorly impressed. Barnes and Noble has been saying for some time now that they will only continue to provide "showroom space" for those titles for which they also have electronic access. (This was in a PW article some months ago, which I cannot find now but I promise my word is good for it.) At the time I thought that this was a load of hot air, quite frankly, because who would risk that much to take a stance against that behemoth of Amazon? Again, I understand the objections to it, but you have to admit to the sheer amount of chutzpah that a move like that takes. I also have no love for Amazon, who does not even have the redeeming aspect of employing booksellers to soften the blow of how many stores they have helped put under. So I admit that I did not regret that DC might have had their noses tweaked a little for relying so heavily on Amazon.
I also think B&N has a point. Booksellers everywhere can understand the frustration of having someone come in, ask you to find a book, and then go buy it online. Watch this video from the Harvard Bookstore, which humorously but accurately depicts the frustration of watching your hard work benefit another company. For Indies, they rely on the goodwill of their customers to support their local bookstore to get people to buy actual paper copies, and people respond to that. B&N, who can't reap the benefits of being a "local", relies on being able to sell their products electronically as well to keep their customers loyal. Without that ability, it really doesn't profit them to keep a title in stock that people will just come in and look at, listen to the employee recommendations, and buy elsewhere.
Do they lose the sales from people not being able to buy the paper copy? Sure, but they've seen what happens when a company relies on just being cheap and there, rather than aggressively expanding into the electronic world. Right or wrong, they seem to be taking a stand against the idea that they exist solely as showroom space, and refuse to participate in a system in which they are not seeing any benefit for themselves.
Now it seems that Books-A-Million has joined the embargo. If I may make a Star Trek reference, it's as if one of the non-aligned worlds has joined the Maquis forces and lent them a semblance of legitimacy so they look less like a spoiled child throwing tantrums over things that they cannot change. It will be interesting to see if this move will sway customer sympathy in their favor. This "alliance" make the issue less about Barnes and Noble, and more about the book industry as a whole. While I'm sure B&N comic book revenue is nothing to sneeze at, adding BAM numbers to the equation makes things a little more serious if DC wants to continue this way.
It will also be interesting to see how the Indies react to this "call to arms". I would venture to say that since there is nothing that would really benefit them to help either Barnes and Noble or BAM, they will probably sit this one out. More than either of these chains, the Indie relies on having the physical product for the regulars and for the walk-ins. They therefore can't really afford to do anything drastic over electronic content, and in any case a lot of them don't offer their own e-reader anyway. However, it may benefit the book-selling industry as whole to remind publishers that they need their showroom as much as book stores need the product.
Surprisingly, I don't really feel strongly one way or the other about this battle. I think it is intensely interesting, and I have always had something of a soft spot for lost causes, but the objections against this move are very valid. Beyond the question of whether or not they are right to be doing what they are doing, there is also the chance that this won't pan out, and they will have alienated their customer base for nothing.
What about you? Do you feel that bookstores have the right to refuse to carry product that they do not have access to electronically? Or do you feel that bookstores have a responsibility to the community that they are in to have the good titles in stock, and that they are only hurting themselves in the long run? I'm curious to hear what people at other bookstores or even those not involved in the industry think. While the book industry has always been rather insular, I think the most important thing going forward is to hear what the concerns and responses are of the community you serve.
After all, isn't that what rebel causes are for?
Saturday, September 17, 2011
The Question of Queer in YA
Most people are aware of the problems queer Young Adult literature faces in the publishing industry, and indeed the media in general. As a bookseller, I am often saddened by the lack of queer protagonists, with some notable exceptions (Will Grayson, Will Grayson, Ash, The Bermudez Triangle). Anyone who has any contact at all in the book industry will tell you that this is a problem.
It is a problem because kids who are queer, and even those that aren't, need to see queer themes more often. While I've never had someone ask directly for a title in that section with those themes, I well remember how much I longed for something like that when I was a teenager. I would never have asked, but it would have meant the world to me, to see myself represented in that fashion. I was always looking for the subtext, always looking for themes of tolerence and acceptance but through the lense of genetics or aliens... I don't really have the words for how happy I would have been, to find a story that actually put it out there. I never found such a title, but I am glad they exist now, but there still aren't enough. Kids that don't have the support network I did need it, and they need more than a couple titles on the shelves.
Growing increasingly problematic are the responses to this issue that have begun to crop up recently.
When I read this article on the Publishers Weekly blog, it was not shocking, that they had been rejected based on a character's sexual orientation. Sad, but not shocking, as evidenced by how few titles are on the shelves that deal with this issue. Again, subtext is great in it's way, but it doesn't really count as a morale booster for kids who are queer. Then there are those who are actively working against queer acceptance in YA literature, which actively hurts those who are young enough to be impressionable. As in the post I made previously, it seems that people who fit the hetero-normative profile won't read things about people that don't, even though the reverse is true. I liked this article when I first read it, as it talked about concepts I agreed with and was trying to generate support for those wronged and held hope that the system could be changed.
Then this article was released, which basically claims that the authors at the very least misunderstood the criticisms they were given, at the worst that they were exploiting the issue. Now, I won't pretend that I actually know one way or another what exactly is going on in this situation. In any case, the agency in question claims that it wasn't about the sexuality of the characters, but the overall writing choices to which they objected. The rebuttal to the rebuttal can be found here, if you are interested in the back and forth of the situation.
I feel the situation is in danger of becoming one fueled by drama. It's a topic that pushes a lot of buttons, and generates a lot of emotion. It makes me sad that what could have been a lovely opener on this issue has, warranted or not, lost some of its validity due to the circumstances surrounding it. This is all the more disheartening because there are those that would argue that there is no need for representation of minority characters. These detractors would say that if there are authors who say that they have good stories about that they can't sell, they are making it up. I'm not saying that this is what has happened here, but I wonder at the motivation behind calling out someone who may only be trying to begin the conversation. However, given that the issue appears to be devolving into a he-said-she-said affair, will people outside the industry still be willing to listen? I hope so, but they might not be, and the missed opportunity saddens me most of all.
Even more distressing, The Mary Sue released this article about the subject, which was written by Aja Romano, an author I have read before and very much admire. The article itself is well written and raises good points, yet I find I must disagree with the solution that she proposes. She suggests that rather than wade through the mire of the publishing industry, that authors should just self-publish on the internet, or release their work for free.
One problem with this argument is the issue of editing. While one could argue that an determined (and finanically independent) author could do the same marketing job as agents and publishing houses, they do serve a very vital function: they edit and critique. Now, it is possible that an author knows someone who is very good at doing these things and is willing to do it on a freelance basis. Again, the issue here is money, and an author could sink quite a bit on an editor for a work that may not ever be bringing in profit. A lot of authors do not have this resource, and so must rely on friends or family members to help where they can. A friend is good for overall impression of your work, but they most likely have not been trained to be an editor, and would not give you the same feedback. Anyone that is your friend first and your editor second is also going to have a hard time being objective about your work, which is critical to the process. This leads a lot of self-published works to reflect the low quality of the editing, even though the story itself may be good. The reality is that often consumers don't bother with buying self-published titles on Amazon and the like, because there is such a plethora of un-edited, terrible works or just plain plagiarized titles that it gets to be too much to wade through.
Most authors talk about their editors the same way some athletes talk about their coaches: while they are behind the scenes and never get much credit they are completely vital. Could one still self-publish a book and have it be good and profitable? Of course. I have no doubt that many people can and do, but to not mention the downsides to doing it without an editor or an agent would be a little disingenuous. Although agents don't do as much in the editing side of things, they still perform a vital function in terms of representing your work, negotiating the legal side of things, and just in general being the person who is completely on your side. Rejecting the idustry in its entirety also ignores the agents and publishing houses who do publish queer or minority centered books, and rather than reward them for their courage, denies them the chance to continue publishing such works.
The second problem with this solution is, as you might have guessed given my current profession, is that works self-published online will never go through a brick-and-mortar store and thus contributes to the dwindling state of bookstores. I acknowledge my bias in this case, but I don't think that it invalidates the point.
While the internet allows your work to be seen by many thousands of people who would not otherwise have seen it, you are also limiting who sees it. People who don't use e-books, and there are still those out there who do not, will not get a chance to read your work. This is particularly important when we talk about the YA genre, since the main point here is that queer teens would benefit so much from seeing themselves represented and teens use e-readers much less than adults. While e-readership has grown among teens recently, what about the teens who cannot afford e-readers? Many kids still only read what is required reading in schools, and most teachers still teach print only books. College is moving away from print text books and the like, but the younger a student gets the more teachers rely on paper to teach. These younger students are the ones it is most important to reach, and the ones most likely to be left out.
Taking the bookstore out also takes the bookseller out of the equation. When people ask me why it is important to have brick-and-mortar stores to sell books, I usually say that a mathematical algorithm doesn't really understand why you like certain books, and couldn't help you find something that would suit your taste but is outside of what you normally look at. There is something about a bookstore itself that allows a sense of discovery, that pushes at your boundaries a little, that invites you to try something new. As this piece points out, there is a reason that people say that a bookstore closing is a sad thing. Part of the power of books lies in the ability they have to force the reader to see things from another point of view. Kids who aren't looking for it won't get those titles put in their "suggested" list, and so miss out. The same is true for adults who might also benefit from having their horizons broadened.
Parents also rely on booksellers to recommend titles that are good and appropriate for their kids. YA is a broad age range, and what is appropriate for a 17 year-old is not always appropriate for a 13 year-old. Parents utilize booksellers as a way to know the difference, so that they can be sure they are buying books that won't suddenly throw a sex scene at a kid who is perhaps not ready to handle it. Or, if they are okay with their kids reading such material, they want to know it is in there so that they can be prepared to talk about it with them. I worry that more parents will react like this to the young adult genre without the aid of booksellers to navigate the section. I don't want parents to get to the point where they start restricting what their kids read blindly because they can't find anyone whose opinions they trust.
I do believe that the internet is an awesome place to put free, queer friendly things for teens. As a teenager, I found solace in fan-fiction that expressed what real books did not, so I completely understand where that sentiment is coming from. However, I still always had the sense of missing out on something, because I had to stare at a computer screen instead of reading one of my beloved books to get the stories I wanted. If you wish to release your work for free on the internet, please do so, but don't do it just because it is easier than fighting for what is right.
Self-publishing online is indeed a viable option, but I feel it is only one that should be used if you have exhausted all other options. As this agent says, it takes time to sell a book, and sometimes all that is required is patience. It hurts the book-selling industry, especially those who rely on good works being printed in order to keep their jobs, when talented people give up before they even try. I would argue that it also hurts rather than helps the many teens that are starved for stories of themselves, and does nothing at all to change the minds of people who would dismiss the topic out of hand. This is a problem, one that needs to be addressed, but the solutions are not to give up, or cause unnecessary drama about it.
So let's all take a deep breath, and get back to the business of writing, promoting, buying and reading these works that are so desperately needed.
It is a problem because kids who are queer, and even those that aren't, need to see queer themes more often. While I've never had someone ask directly for a title in that section with those themes, I well remember how much I longed for something like that when I was a teenager. I would never have asked, but it would have meant the world to me, to see myself represented in that fashion. I was always looking for the subtext, always looking for themes of tolerence and acceptance but through the lense of genetics or aliens... I don't really have the words for how happy I would have been, to find a story that actually put it out there. I never found such a title, but I am glad they exist now, but there still aren't enough. Kids that don't have the support network I did need it, and they need more than a couple titles on the shelves.
Growing increasingly problematic are the responses to this issue that have begun to crop up recently.
When I read this article on the Publishers Weekly blog, it was not shocking, that they had been rejected based on a character's sexual orientation. Sad, but not shocking, as evidenced by how few titles are on the shelves that deal with this issue. Again, subtext is great in it's way, but it doesn't really count as a morale booster for kids who are queer. Then there are those who are actively working against queer acceptance in YA literature, which actively hurts those who are young enough to be impressionable. As in the post I made previously, it seems that people who fit the hetero-normative profile won't read things about people that don't, even though the reverse is true. I liked this article when I first read it, as it talked about concepts I agreed with and was trying to generate support for those wronged and held hope that the system could be changed.
Then this article was released, which basically claims that the authors at the very least misunderstood the criticisms they were given, at the worst that they were exploiting the issue. Now, I won't pretend that I actually know one way or another what exactly is going on in this situation. In any case, the agency in question claims that it wasn't about the sexuality of the characters, but the overall writing choices to which they objected. The rebuttal to the rebuttal can be found here, if you are interested in the back and forth of the situation.
I feel the situation is in danger of becoming one fueled by drama. It's a topic that pushes a lot of buttons, and generates a lot of emotion. It makes me sad that what could have been a lovely opener on this issue has, warranted or not, lost some of its validity due to the circumstances surrounding it. This is all the more disheartening because there are those that would argue that there is no need for representation of minority characters. These detractors would say that if there are authors who say that they have good stories about that they can't sell, they are making it up. I'm not saying that this is what has happened here, but I wonder at the motivation behind calling out someone who may only be trying to begin the conversation. However, given that the issue appears to be devolving into a he-said-she-said affair, will people outside the industry still be willing to listen? I hope so, but they might not be, and the missed opportunity saddens me most of all.
Even more distressing, The Mary Sue released this article about the subject, which was written by Aja Romano, an author I have read before and very much admire. The article itself is well written and raises good points, yet I find I must disagree with the solution that she proposes. She suggests that rather than wade through the mire of the publishing industry, that authors should just self-publish on the internet, or release their work for free.
One problem with this argument is the issue of editing. While one could argue that an determined (and finanically independent) author could do the same marketing job as agents and publishing houses, they do serve a very vital function: they edit and critique. Now, it is possible that an author knows someone who is very good at doing these things and is willing to do it on a freelance basis. Again, the issue here is money, and an author could sink quite a bit on an editor for a work that may not ever be bringing in profit. A lot of authors do not have this resource, and so must rely on friends or family members to help where they can. A friend is good for overall impression of your work, but they most likely have not been trained to be an editor, and would not give you the same feedback. Anyone that is your friend first and your editor second is also going to have a hard time being objective about your work, which is critical to the process. This leads a lot of self-published works to reflect the low quality of the editing, even though the story itself may be good. The reality is that often consumers don't bother with buying self-published titles on Amazon and the like, because there is such a plethora of un-edited, terrible works or just plain plagiarized titles that it gets to be too much to wade through.
Most authors talk about their editors the same way some athletes talk about their coaches: while they are behind the scenes and never get much credit they are completely vital. Could one still self-publish a book and have it be good and profitable? Of course. I have no doubt that many people can and do, but to not mention the downsides to doing it without an editor or an agent would be a little disingenuous. Although agents don't do as much in the editing side of things, they still perform a vital function in terms of representing your work, negotiating the legal side of things, and just in general being the person who is completely on your side. Rejecting the idustry in its entirety also ignores the agents and publishing houses who do publish queer or minority centered books, and rather than reward them for their courage, denies them the chance to continue publishing such works.
The second problem with this solution is, as you might have guessed given my current profession, is that works self-published online will never go through a brick-and-mortar store and thus contributes to the dwindling state of bookstores. I acknowledge my bias in this case, but I don't think that it invalidates the point.
While the internet allows your work to be seen by many thousands of people who would not otherwise have seen it, you are also limiting who sees it. People who don't use e-books, and there are still those out there who do not, will not get a chance to read your work. This is particularly important when we talk about the YA genre, since the main point here is that queer teens would benefit so much from seeing themselves represented and teens use e-readers much less than adults. While e-readership has grown among teens recently, what about the teens who cannot afford e-readers? Many kids still only read what is required reading in schools, and most teachers still teach print only books. College is moving away from print text books and the like, but the younger a student gets the more teachers rely on paper to teach. These younger students are the ones it is most important to reach, and the ones most likely to be left out.
Taking the bookstore out also takes the bookseller out of the equation. When people ask me why it is important to have brick-and-mortar stores to sell books, I usually say that a mathematical algorithm doesn't really understand why you like certain books, and couldn't help you find something that would suit your taste but is outside of what you normally look at. There is something about a bookstore itself that allows a sense of discovery, that pushes at your boundaries a little, that invites you to try something new. As this piece points out, there is a reason that people say that a bookstore closing is a sad thing. Part of the power of books lies in the ability they have to force the reader to see things from another point of view. Kids who aren't looking for it won't get those titles put in their "suggested" list, and so miss out. The same is true for adults who might also benefit from having their horizons broadened.
Parents also rely on booksellers to recommend titles that are good and appropriate for their kids. YA is a broad age range, and what is appropriate for a 17 year-old is not always appropriate for a 13 year-old. Parents utilize booksellers as a way to know the difference, so that they can be sure they are buying books that won't suddenly throw a sex scene at a kid who is perhaps not ready to handle it. Or, if they are okay with their kids reading such material, they want to know it is in there so that they can be prepared to talk about it with them. I worry that more parents will react like this to the young adult genre without the aid of booksellers to navigate the section. I don't want parents to get to the point where they start restricting what their kids read blindly because they can't find anyone whose opinions they trust.
I do believe that the internet is an awesome place to put free, queer friendly things for teens. As a teenager, I found solace in fan-fiction that expressed what real books did not, so I completely understand where that sentiment is coming from. However, I still always had the sense of missing out on something, because I had to stare at a computer screen instead of reading one of my beloved books to get the stories I wanted. If you wish to release your work for free on the internet, please do so, but don't do it just because it is easier than fighting for what is right.
Self-publishing online is indeed a viable option, but I feel it is only one that should be used if you have exhausted all other options. As this agent says, it takes time to sell a book, and sometimes all that is required is patience. It hurts the book-selling industry, especially those who rely on good works being printed in order to keep their jobs, when talented people give up before they even try. I would argue that it also hurts rather than helps the many teens that are starved for stories of themselves, and does nothing at all to change the minds of people who would dismiss the topic out of hand. This is a problem, one that needs to be addressed, but the solutions are not to give up, or cause unnecessary drama about it.
So let's all take a deep breath, and get back to the business of writing, promoting, buying and reading these works that are so desperately needed.
Thursday, September 8, 2011
Moment of Squee - Thermal Ink
Okay, so this has not been a weekly thing, but I am going to try to post "Moment of Squee" more often.
Today's squee comes from an article at Brain Pickings about Jordan Crane's new kids book - Keep Our Secrets. In a blend of science and whimsy that is full of awesome, it uses thermal ink to hide messages and images in the book, which are revealed at the touch of your hand. Check it out!
As a bookseller these kinds of things are really exciting, especially because I think that creative projects like these are what will help keep the brick-and-mortar bookstores in business. After all, you can't do that on a Kindle.
Today's squee comes from an article at Brain Pickings about Jordan Crane's new kids book - Keep Our Secrets. In a blend of science and whimsy that is full of awesome, it uses thermal ink to hide messages and images in the book, which are revealed at the touch of your hand. Check it out!
As a bookseller these kinds of things are really exciting, especially because I think that creative projects like these are what will help keep the brick-and-mortar bookstores in business. After all, you can't do that on a Kindle.
Sunday, August 21, 2011
Sulking in the Clubhouse
I have this game I play every Christmas. It's called, "Find A Book For My Little Brother".This game is much harder than it sounds, because while my brother is extremely intelligent he won't seek out books on his own. I've been playing this game since he was 14 years old, so I've gotten pretty good at it. He likes books with a lot of action, and he prefers them with a male protagonist. For those of you who have never tried to buy these kinds of books, they are sometimes hard to find in an age appropriate section. It's a struggle at times, that's why I spend a good few weeks thinking over before making my final purchase. The thing is, every year I find something. Some years are harder than others, and I'm not ashamed to say that The Lightning Thief series supplied a few Christmases, but every year I give him one and he reads it. I'm not saying he loves every single one, but I can at least get him to read it.
When I hear about how hard it is to get boys to read, I can sympathize with the concept. It's a struggle to get my brother, who doesn't outright hate reading, to read for pleasure, so I can imagine the frustration of parents with kids who actively avoid it. I get to hear about it frequently at work, as parents try desperately to find something, anything that will spark their child's interest. But again, I always find something. Most often the parent comes back, saying that he wants more of the same. Those are good days, made nicer because it was somewhat of a challenge.
So I hope I don't sound too dismissive when I say that this article by Robert Lipsyte was the whiniest and most self righteous article I've read in a long time, and that's saying something. This article is purportedly about finding the cause for the lack of boy readers, but it seems to be doing more blaming a large female readership than being concerned with how boys are taught at a young age that they should never try to understand girl things, including books.
Lipsyte begins the article with a story about a panel at which he and some other male authors have been asked to speak, in hopes that they, as successful and talented writers, could enlighten the audience as to how they can reach out to boy readers. He says,
"We guys had mixed feelings about the game plan: boys’ aversion to reading, let alone to novels, has been worsening for years. But while this certainly posed a problem for us male writers, we felt that we were being treated as a sideshow.
And so we turned from men into boys. Though we ranged in age and style....we easily slipped into a cohesive pack. We became stereotypes, smart-aleck teammates — and we were very much on the defensive. It was Us vs. Them. This is exactly what boys do, in the classroom and in the library, as well as in the clubhouse."
When I hear about how hard it is to get boys to read, I can sympathize with the concept. It's a struggle to get my brother, who doesn't outright hate reading, to read for pleasure, so I can imagine the frustration of parents with kids who actively avoid it. I get to hear about it frequently at work, as parents try desperately to find something, anything that will spark their child's interest. But again, I always find something. Most often the parent comes back, saying that he wants more of the same. Those are good days, made nicer because it was somewhat of a challenge.
So I hope I don't sound too dismissive when I say that this article by Robert Lipsyte was the whiniest and most self righteous article I've read in a long time, and that's saying something. This article is purportedly about finding the cause for the lack of boy readers, but it seems to be doing more blaming a large female readership than being concerned with how boys are taught at a young age that they should never try to understand girl things, including books.
Lipsyte begins the article with a story about a panel at which he and some other male authors have been asked to speak, in hopes that they, as successful and talented writers, could enlighten the audience as to how they can reach out to boy readers. He says,
"We guys had mixed feelings about the game plan: boys’ aversion to reading, let alone to novels, has been worsening for years. But while this certainly posed a problem for us male writers, we felt that we were being treated as a sideshow.
And so we turned from men into boys. Though we ranged in age and style....we easily slipped into a cohesive pack. We became stereotypes, smart-aleck teammates — and we were very much on the defensive. It was Us vs. Them. This is exactly what boys do, in the classroom and in the library, as well as in the clubhouse."
First of all, if they had intended to treat you as a sideshow, would there be a bunch of authors, any number of whom are probably talented, hardworking and have much better things to do with their time, be waiting to listen to you? If they didn't care to hear your thoughts on it, why would they be there? Oh, right, because it was an "overwhelmingly female audience", they must have just been there to cry and wave their dollies at you. Why did you feel the need to go on defensive? Why the "Us Vs. Them" mentality? If you really care so much about boys reading, why don't you want women to write those books?
Also, this is what boys do because they are children who don't know any better. Just like girls do stupid things when they are small, boys do nonsense that they eventually grow out of if they want to be treated like adults. This happens for both genders, and part of growing up is learning how to tell the difference between you feeling uncomfortable about a certain subject and someone attacking you for talking about it. You learn to distinguish the two and react accordingly. Except for when they are intelligent male authors being sincerely asked their opinions, apparently.
I get that boys not reading is a problem, although I'd really have loved to see some statistics backing up these claims of lower reading numbers. Instead of this hard evidence, Lipsyte names the "standard answers" to why boys don't read, including that boys, "don’t feel comfortable exploring the emotions and feelings found in fiction. . . . Boys don’t have enough positive male role models for literacy. Because the majority of adults involved in kids’ reading are women, boys might not see reading as a masculine activity.”
Are there a lot of female authors on the shelves in the YA section? Yes. Is a lot of it too focused on the romantic attachments between girls and their oddly elder supernatural boyfriends? I mean, I think so. But my definition of what makes a good book is my own, and it may differ from others. I have learned not to behave like a spoiled child if not everyone likes what I like. If it allows a bridge between the unrealistic Disney Princess movies into the realm of the written word, then, well, maybe that Vampire Diaries fan will read Paper Towns next. It will be interesting to see if this crop of girls who are growing up in this YA boom will be more active readers in the future. My guess is that they will.
As with the last rant I did on critiques of an entire section, I would also argue that a good bookseller will help you navigate these apparently treacherous shores, and find something that will appeal to boys to recommend. Do I wish there were more authors who wrote for boys? Sure, but somehow I think they become less inclined to do so when the male author they go to for advice starts ranting about how their inherent female-ness gets his back up. I also think that this is more of a problem of how the books are marketed as opposed to their content, but rather than asking books to all conform to a male sensibility, there has to be a way to get to the root of the problem: our faulty gender stereotypes.
What infuriates me beyond belief about this article is how much it de-values the cognitive capacity of young male readers. Boys are just as capable of reading girl books as visa versa, it is only that we do not expect them to do so. Women don't have some special gene that allows them to enjoy reading from a male perspective, they read male authors because as Maureen Johnson says, "We have little choice in the matter." Women read things by and about boys because they must, but you might notice that before all those female authors burst onto the scene, girls read less in their teenage years than they do now. (If you don't believe me on YA reading rates increasing recently, check out this NEA survey on reading, which ironically has male readership numbers up as well as female.) It's just that there wasn't the ridiculous amount of shaming on girls who read "male" works, so they could at least read something. This is mostly due to the fact that men write good things, and women write girly things, which are not good. If you don't believe me on this, ask any bookseller why Nicholas Sparks is in the fiction section instead of romance.
I propose that instead of shaking the finger at women authors and readers, who have every right to be proud of their success, instead ask why it is that a boy might hide the book he is reading for fear of being called a sissy. Ask why playing sports is a "male" activity, while reading is a passive and "female" activity. Then, stop asking why and start working to undermine that conception. After all, gender is a construct, so maybe we should be asking how to show boys that they won't turn into girls if they read about trying on dresses, just like girls don't turn into boys when they read about refusing to sleep with a prostitute. I may not have liked that book, but it gave me insight into the struggles that boys sometimes have. After all, isn't learning to read inherently the task of learning to view the world through another's eyes? Why is the female perspective on the world any less valued and needful than the male?
I'll give you a hint Mr. Lipsyte: it isn't. The sooner we come down off our fences and work together on this, the sooner we can get those sensitive grown men you so desperately desire.
Also, this is what boys do because they are children who don't know any better. Just like girls do stupid things when they are small, boys do nonsense that they eventually grow out of if they want to be treated like adults. This happens for both genders, and part of growing up is learning how to tell the difference between you feeling uncomfortable about a certain subject and someone attacking you for talking about it. You learn to distinguish the two and react accordingly. Except for when they are intelligent male authors being sincerely asked their opinions, apparently.
I get that boys not reading is a problem, although I'd really have loved to see some statistics backing up these claims of lower reading numbers. Instead of this hard evidence, Lipsyte names the "standard answers" to why boys don't read, including that boys, "don’t feel comfortable exploring the emotions and feelings found in fiction. . . . Boys don’t have enough positive male role models for literacy. Because the majority of adults involved in kids’ reading are women, boys might not see reading as a masculine activity.”
I...what? No positive male role models for literacy? Are you kidding? Kids, think back to when you were in school, and since Lispyte writes YA, let's focus on high school. How many of the books you can remember reading were written by male authors? For myself, I remember mostly male authors, certainly most that are regarded as "classics" were written by men. I do remember reading a good number of contemporary books by women, but I went to an all girls school, and I've heard it is less like that at co-eds. Perhaps we are speaking of contemporary role models? While it is true that there are more women authors on the shelves of the young adult genre, there are certainly more than zero. Yes, James Patterson, I'm looking at you.
My favorite part comes next, when having acknowledged the "standard" (and in my opinion, more pressing) problem of boys feeling that reading is an inherently effeminate activity, he moves on to what he feels is the real problem. What might that be, you ask?
"The current surge in children’s literature has been fueled by talented young female novelists fresh from M.F.A. programs who in earlier times would have been writing midlist adult fiction. Their novels are bought by female editors, stocked by female librarians and taught by female teachers. It’s a cliché but mostly true that while teenage girls will read books about boys, teenage boys will rarely read books with predominately female characters."
TOO. MANY. GIRLS. How DARE these women want to write books that girls would relate to, and how dare women teach as they have been doing ever since we told them they couldn't join the business world?! Quick, run up to the tree-house until the sea of estrogen has ebbed! I also love the casual back-handed compliment paid to the female authors of YA, "talented sure, but they should really be writing in the male-dominated adult fiction section so that their works don't get as much attention". Then the diatribe reaches new levels by suggesting that female teachers don't take into consideration the needs and tastes of their male students, which is even more insulting, if that's possible.
"The current surge in children’s literature has been fueled by talented young female novelists fresh from M.F.A. programs who in earlier times would have been writing midlist adult fiction. Their novels are bought by female editors, stocked by female librarians and taught by female teachers. It’s a cliché but mostly true that while teenage girls will read books about boys, teenage boys will rarely read books with predominately female characters."
TOO. MANY. GIRLS. How DARE these women want to write books that girls would relate to, and how dare women teach as they have been doing ever since we told them they couldn't join the business world?! Quick, run up to the tree-house until the sea of estrogen has ebbed! I also love the casual back-handed compliment paid to the female authors of YA, "talented sure, but they should really be writing in the male-dominated adult fiction section so that their works don't get as much attention". Then the diatribe reaches new levels by suggesting that female teachers don't take into consideration the needs and tastes of their male students, which is even more insulting, if that's possible.
Lipsyte's ending solution is for people to buy/teach kids his book, or at least write things like it, which he apparently feels are the only good contemporary offering for boys. I don't doubt that his books have inspired children to read (after all people who win awards are ALWAYS suitable to be teaching life lessons to children), and I'm a fan of anything that gets kids reading, but seriously. The solution is to put MORE books by male writers on the syllabus? Especially ones that, oh gee, have sports as the main subject line? Well fellas, we could only reach you if we do it through sports, which if you don't like then clearly you are a girl. Christ man, it's almost like you'd rather not have guys learn to read books by women.
This, I feel, is the real sticking point of the article. Rather than try to tackle the issues of shaming and gay bashing that are a staple of a young man's life by standing against them and insisting that there is nothing wrong with reading things from a female perspective, it seems that he would rather hide in his club-house and blame it on the girls. Ah, it is indeed amazing how many solutions are MORE SPORTS AND LESS GIRL, and how caring and intelligent the men are that suggest it. Again, I do believe that he believes in getting boys to read, he just seems to think that somehow this could be solved if women just wrote less, or if we had more books that are clearly not selling anyways.
Are there a lot of female authors on the shelves in the YA section? Yes. Is a lot of it too focused on the romantic attachments between girls and their oddly elder supernatural boyfriends? I mean, I think so. But my definition of what makes a good book is my own, and it may differ from others. I have learned not to behave like a spoiled child if not everyone likes what I like. If it allows a bridge between the unrealistic Disney Princess movies into the realm of the written word, then, well, maybe that Vampire Diaries fan will read Paper Towns next. It will be interesting to see if this crop of girls who are growing up in this YA boom will be more active readers in the future. My guess is that they will.
As with the last rant I did on critiques of an entire section, I would also argue that a good bookseller will help you navigate these apparently treacherous shores, and find something that will appeal to boys to recommend. Do I wish there were more authors who wrote for boys? Sure, but somehow I think they become less inclined to do so when the male author they go to for advice starts ranting about how their inherent female-ness gets his back up. I also think that this is more of a problem of how the books are marketed as opposed to their content, but rather than asking books to all conform to a male sensibility, there has to be a way to get to the root of the problem: our faulty gender stereotypes.
What infuriates me beyond belief about this article is how much it de-values the cognitive capacity of young male readers. Boys are just as capable of reading girl books as visa versa, it is only that we do not expect them to do so. Women don't have some special gene that allows them to enjoy reading from a male perspective, they read male authors because as Maureen Johnson says, "We have little choice in the matter." Women read things by and about boys because they must, but you might notice that before all those female authors burst onto the scene, girls read less in their teenage years than they do now. (If you don't believe me on YA reading rates increasing recently, check out this NEA survey on reading, which ironically has male readership numbers up as well as female.) It's just that there wasn't the ridiculous amount of shaming on girls who read "male" works, so they could at least read something. This is mostly due to the fact that men write good things, and women write girly things, which are not good. If you don't believe me on this, ask any bookseller why Nicholas Sparks is in the fiction section instead of romance.
I propose that instead of shaking the finger at women authors and readers, who have every right to be proud of their success, instead ask why it is that a boy might hide the book he is reading for fear of being called a sissy. Ask why playing sports is a "male" activity, while reading is a passive and "female" activity. Then, stop asking why and start working to undermine that conception. After all, gender is a construct, so maybe we should be asking how to show boys that they won't turn into girls if they read about trying on dresses, just like girls don't turn into boys when they read about refusing to sleep with a prostitute. I may not have liked that book, but it gave me insight into the struggles that boys sometimes have. After all, isn't learning to read inherently the task of learning to view the world through another's eyes? Why is the female perspective on the world any less valued and needful than the male?
I'll give you a hint Mr. Lipsyte: it isn't. The sooner we come down off our fences and work together on this, the sooner we can get those sensitive grown men you so desperately desire.
Thursday, August 4, 2011
Weekly moment of Squee - SteamPunk Minions
Work week got you down? Homework piling up, or perhaps you just don't have enough minions to do your Evil Villainous Deeds? Try these little guys out, created by the amazing Joseph Drust.
Look how cute they are! They also do things, like the one below makes sounds!
This one is a FREAKIN' MAGNET!
My personal favorite, who just wants to give you a hug SO BADLY.
At the very least, they are so cute they will cheer up any crappy day. Originally found on The Mary Sue, which is a cool geek/girl/all things awesome web site. Check them and Joe Drust out!
Tuesday, August 2, 2011
Geeks in the Mirror
I would love to say that the inspiration for this piece is not an article written by a more famous person in a more comprehensible manner than I ever could. Sadly, this post is brought to you in part* by Max Barry and his post on Smurfs and Dogs. I swear that it's relevant, and you should probably read it before reading this post. Go ahead, I'll wait.
Right, so we are probably all familiar with the concepts he is talking about in the article. Female protagonists are theoretically not as universally identifiable as male protagonists. This is more or less a fact of life for the early 21st century. While there is a lot of progress being made, you still cannot convince a large part of the American viewing/ reading public to take a female protagonist seriously. I say "American public" not "men" because women go to movies and read books too, and if a large percent of women decided that they are going to do something, they would make it huge. *cough*Twilight*cough* So, it tends to be that if there is a woman in the book or movie, it is usually a side character whose main selling point is that she is female. I don't want to get bogged down in going over this, so watch Nostalgia Chick's video on it, if you really don't believe/ get what I'm saying.
The downsides to this phenomenon are pretty self evident. Not only does it de-value women and their life experience as something that could never be interesting enough to be the main plot, but it also expects that men can't and shouldn't identify with these life experiences. It also means that these characters have to stand for ALL WOMEN EVERYWHERE. Which, lets face it, is impossible. Any character who tries to stand for all of anything is going to fail, because the range of female/human experience is infinite. So they generally go for lowest common denominator, which means that these characters are going to have qualities that most people associate with the word female.
The trouble is, this is not just a problem for teh ladies. This is a problem for every sub-set of mainstream culture who gets "token-ized". I'm not going to talk about ethnic minorities much because well, I'm not super qualified, but if I see one more film where there is only the one non-white character who is EITHER cool or evil, I might go crazy. Again, I shouldn't have to expound on why this is a bad thing. Hollywood has this perception that audiences won't "get it" if they don't present us with these stereotypes. That we would be completely flabbergasted and uncomprehending when presented with anything that isn't a straight white male to identify with as our main protagonist. Again, a lot of progress is being made, but these are exceptions that prove the rule.
My biggest problem with all of this? The fact that geek culture does not seem to be trying to pull itself out of this bias. If we want to talk about straight white males as main characters, think of all the comic book movies that have come out recently. Think about all the video games, with the exception of Portal, where you play a guy as the default. Bioware has been working on the "not-straight" part, and you certainly can play as a girl, but neither of those options have gotten much press in the past. It's like, if we can have a nerdy protagonist we still prefer him to be straight and white.
What I don't understand is why this is still going on. As geeks, shouldn't being counter culture come as second nature? There are women on the Avengers, why did none of them get an origins movie? (Ok, only one in the coming movie, but still) Women are a minority among geeks, but becoming less so all the time. I know I said I wasn't going to talk too much about it, but seriously with no non-white main protagonists. I'll give you that maybe in an urban fantasy or perhaps even a comic book reality, which is still set during our own time, it may be "problematic" to write from the point of view of someone who is not you, i.e. white or male. I qualify this because there are people who are not white or male working in these industries, so I'm not sure it's really all that hard to find a voice for it. However, giving the benefit of the doubt, it is somewhat understandable to not want to offend by "telling it wrong", especially when writing a book rather than working with an actor of color to tell a story honestly.
So what's your excuse, high fantasy? Theoretically, you should have the same freedoms of science fiction, since racial tensions are a thing of the present and not necessarily of the Ages Ago or Future. And don't give me the whole, "But we're in England past!" argument, because ELVES. I'm pretty sure it won't strain anybody's disbelief, especially if handled with the same aplomb Star Trek has always handled it, i.e."This character is not white. It does not in any way effect the story or his ability to tell it, so we are MOVING ON." Also with the no women! I mean, when was the last time since Xena that we saw some ancient fantasy past woman as the actual main character? Shouldn't magic be the great equalizer? Science Fiction has more, but still not a lot. I'm starting to feel like even the kick-ass girl side-characters aren't enough, because despite being better role models it still creates the illusion that there is only one Girl, and she is only THIS WAY. Being weak or kick-ass is not inherent to a gender, and sometimes being strong doesn't mean you aren't objectified needlessly.
What I love about being a geek is that on the internet, your visual self matters far less that your actual self. The whole "it's what's on the inside that counts" means a whole lot more when the people you are interacting with literally cannot see you. It's more important that you like David Tennant when you get on a chat about Dr. Who, because no one can tell and therefore can't care. You could literally be that dinosaur from Toy Story Three for all anyone would know. I enjoy that and I enjoy the message that it sends. That we don't care about all of that bullshit that keeps us apart IRL, but we can come together around the things we enjoy. So...wtf? Why in our biggest contributions to culture are we confined by the same nonsense that keeps Hollywood from hiring Asian actors for Akira? Why do geek girls constantly feel like they have something to prove, and why can't Green Lantern be African-American in the movies too?
I know what all of the easy answers are, but I want the answer that explains how the people who routinely reject reality continue to accept it. If you don't have that answer, then maybe you should start asking the question yourself, and finding ways to help change things.
* Max Barry does not actually endorse this post. Nor do any of the other thousands of things I've linked to in this post. At least...I don't think so *peers into internet*.
Right, so we are probably all familiar with the concepts he is talking about in the article. Female protagonists are theoretically not as universally identifiable as male protagonists. This is more or less a fact of life for the early 21st century. While there is a lot of progress being made, you still cannot convince a large part of the American viewing/ reading public to take a female protagonist seriously. I say "American public" not "men" because women go to movies and read books too, and if a large percent of women decided that they are going to do something, they would make it huge. *cough*Twilight*cough* So, it tends to be that if there is a woman in the book or movie, it is usually a side character whose main selling point is that she is female. I don't want to get bogged down in going over this, so watch Nostalgia Chick's video on it, if you really don't believe/ get what I'm saying.
The downsides to this phenomenon are pretty self evident. Not only does it de-value women and their life experience as something that could never be interesting enough to be the main plot, but it also expects that men can't and shouldn't identify with these life experiences. It also means that these characters have to stand for ALL WOMEN EVERYWHERE. Which, lets face it, is impossible. Any character who tries to stand for all of anything is going to fail, because the range of female/human experience is infinite. So they generally go for lowest common denominator, which means that these characters are going to have qualities that most people associate with the word female.
The trouble is, this is not just a problem for teh ladies. This is a problem for every sub-set of mainstream culture who gets "token-ized". I'm not going to talk about ethnic minorities much because well, I'm not super qualified, but if I see one more film where there is only the one non-white character who is EITHER cool or evil, I might go crazy. Again, I shouldn't have to expound on why this is a bad thing. Hollywood has this perception that audiences won't "get it" if they don't present us with these stereotypes. That we would be completely flabbergasted and uncomprehending when presented with anything that isn't a straight white male to identify with as our main protagonist. Again, a lot of progress is being made, but these are exceptions that prove the rule.
My biggest problem with all of this? The fact that geek culture does not seem to be trying to pull itself out of this bias. If we want to talk about straight white males as main characters, think of all the comic book movies that have come out recently. Think about all the video games, with the exception of Portal, where you play a guy as the default. Bioware has been working on the "not-straight" part, and you certainly can play as a girl, but neither of those options have gotten much press in the past. It's like, if we can have a nerdy protagonist we still prefer him to be straight and white.
What I don't understand is why this is still going on. As geeks, shouldn't being counter culture come as second nature? There are women on the Avengers, why did none of them get an origins movie? (Ok, only one in the coming movie, but still) Women are a minority among geeks, but becoming less so all the time. I know I said I wasn't going to talk too much about it, but seriously with no non-white main protagonists. I'll give you that maybe in an urban fantasy or perhaps even a comic book reality, which is still set during our own time, it may be "problematic" to write from the point of view of someone who is not you, i.e. white or male. I qualify this because there are people who are not white or male working in these industries, so I'm not sure it's really all that hard to find a voice for it. However, giving the benefit of the doubt, it is somewhat understandable to not want to offend by "telling it wrong", especially when writing a book rather than working with an actor of color to tell a story honestly.
So what's your excuse, high fantasy? Theoretically, you should have the same freedoms of science fiction, since racial tensions are a thing of the present and not necessarily of the Ages Ago or Future. And don't give me the whole, "But we're in England past!" argument, because ELVES. I'm pretty sure it won't strain anybody's disbelief, especially if handled with the same aplomb Star Trek has always handled it, i.e."This character is not white. It does not in any way effect the story or his ability to tell it, so we are MOVING ON." Also with the no women! I mean, when was the last time since Xena that we saw some ancient fantasy past woman as the actual main character? Shouldn't magic be the great equalizer? Science Fiction has more, but still not a lot. I'm starting to feel like even the kick-ass girl side-characters aren't enough, because despite being better role models it still creates the illusion that there is only one Girl, and she is only THIS WAY. Being weak or kick-ass is not inherent to a gender, and sometimes being strong doesn't mean you aren't objectified needlessly.
What I love about being a geek is that on the internet, your visual self matters far less that your actual self. The whole "it's what's on the inside that counts" means a whole lot more when the people you are interacting with literally cannot see you. It's more important that you like David Tennant when you get on a chat about Dr. Who, because no one can tell and therefore can't care. You could literally be that dinosaur from Toy Story Three for all anyone would know. I enjoy that and I enjoy the message that it sends. That we don't care about all of that bullshit that keeps us apart IRL, but we can come together around the things we enjoy. So...wtf? Why in our biggest contributions to culture are we confined by the same nonsense that keeps Hollywood from hiring Asian actors for Akira? Why do geek girls constantly feel like they have something to prove, and why can't Green Lantern be African-American in the movies too?
I know what all of the easy answers are, but I want the answer that explains how the people who routinely reject reality continue to accept it. If you don't have that answer, then maybe you should start asking the question yourself, and finding ways to help change things.
* Max Barry does not actually endorse this post. Nor do any of the other thousands of things I've linked to in this post. At least...I don't think so *peers into internet*.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)